The following is a collection of book reviews by four teens (identified here by their initials) who read Holly Jackson’s novel, A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder. All four teens rated the book 5/5 stars. What makes it so good? Should you read it, too? Read on!
Grammar and spelling in some reviews have been edited for clarity.
Summary (provided by the publisher):
Everyone in Fairview knows the story.
Pretty and popular high school senior Andie Bell was murdered by her boyfriend, Sal Singh, who then killed himself. It was all anyone could talk about. And five years later, Pip sees how the tragedy still haunts her town.
But she can’t shake the feeling that there was more to what happened that day. She knew Sal when she was a child, and he was always so kind to her. How could he possibly have been a killer?
Now a senior herself, Pip decides to reexamine the closed case for her final project, at first just to cast doubt on the original investigation. But soon she discovers a trail of dark secrets that might actually prove Sal innocent . . . and the line between past and present begins to blur. Someone in Fairview doesn’t want Pip digging around for answers, and now her own life might be in danger.
Use 5 words to describe this material.
OM: Truth, justice, friendship, reputation, mystery
GF: Mystery, suspenseful, confusing, thought-provoking, and compelling
KA: Mysterious, action-filled, suspenseful, perseverance, and thrilling
MH: Captivating, thrilling, entertaining, suspenseful, shocking
Why did you read/view this material?
OM: It is a New York Times bestseller and friends were recommending it.
GF: I read this book because my friend recommended it to me and it looked like a very interesting book.
KA: I read this book because of how it was getting amazing reviews and also because of how I wanted to read the whole series.
MH: I read A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder because it was popular and I am interested in the genre of murder mysteries.
What was your favorite part and why?
OM: The surprise twist at the end. This story kept you at the edge of your seat.
GF: My favorite part of the book is when you find out who is behind the whole scene. The buildup in this book is amazing, and I was questioning who actually did it the whole time. The book surprises you with that answer!
KA: My favorite part was when Pip found out who was the true murderer. It was the person I least expected.
MH: My favorite part is the part that must never be spoiled ahead of time, this is the part where everything falls together and Pippa figures everything out. This is my favorite part because it’s so satisfying to see all the clues put together, the ending is so unexpected. It is an ending worthy of Agatha Christie.
What is one thing that you would change about this material? Why?
OM: The beginning is a little confusing, as it switches from first person, to journal entries, to interview transcripts. I had to spend more time than I usually would figuring out what was important to focus on before could I really process the point of the story.
GF: One thing that I would change about this book is giving the outside characters that are still relevant to the book more of a story. In this book, everyone is viewed as a suspect for Pip to investigate, but in reality, every character is different and has their strengths and weaknesses.
KA: Something I would change about this book is how it has pictures. I prefer when books do not have pictures.
If you could ask the author/creator one question about this material, what would it be and why?
OM: I would ask the author how she got the idea because the book states that it is completely fiction. It is such a well thought out and creative story, I would love to know where she gets her inspiration.
GF: If I could meet Holly Jackson and ask her one question about A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder, I would ask her what gave her the idea to write this book. It has very big plot twists and the storyline is complex, so I would ask her how she came up with this.
KA: Something that I would ask Holly Jackson is what inspired her to write a book about this topic. Was it based on a true story/something that really happened?
MH: If I could ask Ms. Jackson one question about A Good Girl’s Guide To Murder, it would be this, how did you come up with your ending? The ending was truly very unexpected and surprising, I would like to know how Ms. Jackson came up with such a unique ending.
Who do you think would like this material and why?
OM: Anyone that enjoys mysteries or realistic fiction would enjoy this book.
GF: I think that teenagers would like this book. This is because it has great characters that most people can relate to, and it has big plot twists that older kids would enjoy.
KA: I think people who like crime/murder related books would like this.
MH: I think anyone thirteen years old or older would enjoy this book, even adults, the plot develops very quickly, yet it is not at all predictable. It is a thrilling and exciting read for anyone, not just true crime geeks.







